WaifanFoodMachine is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more

Best Baking Sheet Pan of 2022: Tested And Reviewed

Jordan Ardoin
  Jul 7, 2022 2:41 PM

Does a kitchen truly qualify as one without sheets (or more than five)? Baking trays made of metal are our go-to for everything from cookies, to roasted vegetables, all the way to complete sheet-pan meals. You might think that metal is just a tiny bit of metal. What can the differences between sheet pans be? They're not all created to be the same, and for an item of kitchen equipment that is as important as a baking pan you'll need to ensure you're buying one that can be durable and last for many years.

The platonic sheet pan we use isn't a wallflower. We want it to be sturdy enough to be used every day without warping under extreme temperatures, and of high-end quality so that food cooks according to the way that it is supposed to, as well as also the proper size to fit into the majority of ovens in homes. To meet all of these requirements as well, look to the legendary Nordic Ware Naturals Aluminium Half-Sheet. It's the most effective sheet pan available, and the BA Test Kitchen is a voted on as a top, long-running favorite best baking sheet pan.


Compare Products

Showing  1 - 10  in  16 results
TOP Choice
1
  • SCORE
    9.6
    AI Score

    AI Score is a ranking system developed by our team of experts. It from 0 to 10 are automatically scored by our AI Consumer Report tool based upon the data collected. This score has no relationship or impact from any manufacturer or sales agent websites. Learn more

  • Brand
    Nordic Ware
Most Saving
2
  • SCORE
    9.6
    AI Score

    AI Score is a ranking system developed by our team of experts. It from 0 to 10 are automatically scored by our AI Consumer Report tool based upon the data collected. This score has no relationship or impact from any manufacturer or sales agent websites. Learn more

  • Brand
    USA Pan
3
  • SCORE
    9.4
    AI Score

    AI Score is a ranking system developed by our team of experts. It from 0 to 10 are automatically scored by our AI Consumer Report tool based upon the data collected. This score has no relationship or impact from any manufacturer or sales agent websites. Learn more

  • Brand
    NutriChef
4
  • SCORE
    9.4
    AI Score

    AI Score is a ranking system developed by our team of experts. It from 0 to 10 are automatically scored by our AI Consumer Report tool based upon the data collected. This score has no relationship or impact from any manufacturer or sales agent websites. Learn more

  • Brand
    M MCIRCO
5
  • SCORE
    9.4
    AI Score

    AI Score is a ranking system developed by our team of experts. It from 0 to 10 are automatically scored by our AI Consumer Report tool based upon the data collected. This score has no relationship or impact from any manufacturer or sales agent websites. Learn more

  • Brand
    Rottay
6
  • SCORE
    9.2
    AI Score

    AI Score is a ranking system developed by our team of experts. It from 0 to 10 are automatically scored by our AI Consumer Report tool based upon the data collected. This score has no relationship or impact from any manufacturer or sales agent websites. Learn more

  • Brand
    Ultra Cuisine
7
  • SCORE
    9.2
    AI Score

    AI Score is a ranking system developed by our team of experts. It from 0 to 10 are automatically scored by our AI Consumer Report tool based upon the data collected. This score has no relationship or impact from any manufacturer or sales agent websites. Learn more

  • Brand
    Zulay Kitchen
8
  • SCORE
    9.2
    AI Score

    AI Score is a ranking system developed by our team of experts. It from 0 to 10 are automatically scored by our AI Consumer Report tool based upon the data collected. This score has no relationship or impact from any manufacturer or sales agent websites. Learn more

  • Brand
    CEKEE
9
  • SCORE
    9.2
    AI Score

    AI Score is a ranking system developed by our team of experts. It from 0 to 10 are automatically scored by our AI Consumer Report tool based upon the data collected. This score has no relationship or impact from any manufacturer or sales agent websites. Learn more

  • Brand
    Wildone
10
  • SCORE
    9.2
    AI Score

    AI Score is a ranking system developed by our team of experts. It from 0 to 10 are automatically scored by our AI Consumer Report tool based upon the data collected. This score has no relationship or impact from any manufacturer or sales agent websites. Learn more

  • Brand
    kitCom

Last update on 2022-07-07 / Affiliate links / Images, Product Titles, and Product Highlights from Amazon Product Advertising API


Buying Guides

Material

In terms of conduction of heat, bare aluminum is the best. It is extremely hot and cools fast so that your food will cook when it is placed in the hot oven, and will cease cooking once it is out. It's also light-colored and gives you greater control over how brown the inside of your cakes, cakes, cookies or pizzas will turn. Aluminum-based steel, made up of steel that has been sandwiched with aluminum is much more vulnerable for uneven distribution of heat. The stainless steel has been widely acknowledged to be an underperformer in this regard and that's why the baking sheet made of stainless steel that we tried was not as reliable.

Size

A typical half-sheet tray measures 18x13" however, Not all half-sheets with rims come with these dimensions. We tested three sheets one was 16x12" one measured 17x11 1/2 " Some were true 18x13" and some were larger, with a variety of sizes between. It's not going to affect whether your vegetables will have a nice char however, if you're cooking in a tiny oven, it can decide if the sheet is suitable for cooking inside.

Nonstick Coating

Nonstick coatings can cause much more hassle than their value. Some aren't very effective , or they will break down with time. They are also more dark in color when contrasted to aluminum models that are bare. These trays that are darker absorb and emit more heat which results in darker outcomes (cookies which were darker rather than gold brown for instance).

Edges Rolled

In contrast to flat-rims, edges that are rolled with a steel rim such as those found on Nordic Ware and Bellemain pans can reduce the chance of warping when there are dramatic shifts in temperature.


4.5
2 ratings